WHODONUT? MURDER MYSTERY JIGSAW PUZZLE Reviews

4.3
(6 Reviews)
Sort by
Dwayne H.  Verified Buyer

FUN!!!
A few co-workers and I competed this puzzle on our lunches and breaks in less than a week.  We loved that there was no a photo.  It added an extra challenge.  The story line was fun and the extra puzzle pieces made it interesting.  Looking forward to the next one.

Was this review helpful? Yes No (0/0)
Tina P.  Verified Buyer

Puzzled by the puzzle.
We have done many of Hunt a Killer's games before and enjoyed several of them.  I'd recommend several other box sets before this one.  Here is our take on some of the key aspects:

Story:  We've always loved the writing for Hunt-a-Killer's stories and this time is no different.  The setup is fairly straight forward and of course all the suspects have a motive.  The extra tidbits from the detective are cute too.

Puzzle:  The idea of a puzzle is great and our family likes putting together puzzles, but this is a 1000 piece that gives you no guidance whatsoever (no picture/box/frame/etc) on what you're putting together.  It is definitely not a single night activity unless you're avid puzzlers.  

I think they didn't provide a picture so you couldn't see the whole picture before you solved the puzzle, but the lack of a picture made it very frustrating to make progress. The puzzle is beautiful and colorful, but the same or similar colors will be used in half a dozen separate places so you're never sure whether things should go together or a piece belongs in a whole other section.    

Puzzle Payoff:  This is probably where we were most disappointed.  We finally completed the puzzle and it felt there was almost no benefit to the case. In order to get the puzzle pieces that hold critical clues you need to answer questions about the case.  But if you are able to answer the questions in the book to get the puzzle pieces then you have pretty much already solved the case.

Overall:  We did enjoy discussing the case even if we got the wrong answer in the end.  The puzzle was more effort than it was worth, but I think it could work in the future.


Was this review helpful? Yes No (3/0)
Desiree J.  Verified Buyer

Hunt a Killer does not disappoint
What a great game! Loved the challenge of putting a puzzle together without a picture but it did take us longer than a hour! We worked on the puzzle for a week- amazing the perspective you get when you walk away.
The murder story and the detective notes were right up there with HAK games.
Hope to see more of these😊


Was this review helpful? Yes No (0/0)
Cicely L.  Verified Buyer

Fun Mystery - be prepared to take some time on the jigsaw puzzle!
This game came out at the perfect time - just as we were going on a family trip. Three of us are big on jigsaw puzzles and we were able to finish the 1000 piece puzzle in three days (we did work on it as constant as we could since we were time limited). The biggest problem to a couple of us was not having a picture of the completed puzzle while doing the puzzle. Having completed the game I don’t think that having a picture of the completed puzzle would have harmed the game. That being said, we loved the mystery! It was fun and the tie-in to the jigsaw puzzle was a fun touch. We solved the mystery within a hour of finishing the puzzle. And the epilogue is a nice touch!! My suggestions would be to get this if you love jigsaw puzzles, and if a picture of the completed puzzle could be included that would be really helpful! (Maybe provide options of puzzles with less pieces, too!)

Was this review helpful? Yes No (1/0)
Sara F.  Verified Buyer

There’s no image provided to put the puzzle together
The mystery part of this exercise is easy enough… but putting together a 1000 piece puzzle with no image to work towards? Good luck. We didn’t have the time or patience for that.

Was this review helpful? Yes No (1/0)